"The Forgotten Garden" by Kate Morton

Four Stars

An unidentified child found abandoned on an Australian dock sets off a multi-generational search for her identity that spans an ocean and an entire century.

This gothic novel has it all dark family secrets, vindictive relatives, a daunting garden maze, even the mysterious and huge old family estate in the English countryside. I love mysteries and I love England so how can this be anything less than awesome? I picked up this book on the recommendation of a friend who said it just might be her new favorite book. When someone gives a book that high of a recommendation how can you say no? That is a lot to live up to and it didn’t disappoint. I wouldn’t rate it as my new favorite, but it is definitely on that list.

The book spans five generations of women, actually six if you count a few comments in passing, starting with number three, mentioning number four, then focusing on five and working backwards. I think the author went a little too far including generations number four and five, not because it becomes too confusing, but because it detracts from the most interesting part of the story that includes generations one through three.

The book draws many similarities from Frances Hodgson Burnett’s “The Secret Garden”, even including a cameo appearance by the author and going so far to imply that this family provided the inspiration for the story.

This book earned four out of five stars because of the extra generations. If it had stuck just to those first three it very well may have earned all five stars. All-in-all I highly recommend it.

There are some SPOILERS after this so there you go, fair warning.

Nell is generation number three and the little girl who was found alone on an Australian dock, but the story is told mainly from the perspective of her granddaughter, Cassandra. She has only a child’s suitcase with a few random possessions as a clue to who she is and where she came from. It’s not until much later in life that she begins the search for her identity which takes her from Australia to England and her family’s estate.

Just as she begins to unravel the long-buried family secrets, her daughter unexpectedly shows up and basically abandons Nell’s granddaughter to her care, effectively ending Nell’s search. Nell raises her granddaughter and eventually dies without ever discovering the truth. It’s only after Nell’s death that Cassandra learns of the secret and decides to find the truth. And this is where it gets too diluted.

Cassandra uses the same clues Nell had and a soggy old notebook Nell kept as a journal during her initial search. Cassandra follows the same path and eventually finds the truth, but the most powerful discoveries are the ones Nell made herself because it is so much more personal to her and she gets answers from people who were there and directly involved. Adding the extra generation of Cassandra was just too detached from the actual story and I found myself almost hurrying through her parts to get to the more interesting parts.